At this point, after Marnie’s backstory is explained in unnecessarily lengthy exposition, it’s entirely clear who Marnie is, and what connection she … Source material: When Marnie Was There by Joan G. Robinson. 13. I have the exact same complaints about Kokurikozaka kara, actually. The storm and the silo were very dramatic, but we find out that scene was not actually particularly meaningful and it's resolved rather easily, almost anticlimactically. Marnie’s delicate nature can be felt through her associations with her setting like her diary entries and disappearance. Due to anxiety attacks, a doctor suggests that Anna move somewhere more relaxing. This film with its themes of loss and relationship, of living through said loss, and the focus on understated relationships/personal moments reminds me of Hotarubi no Mori e (Into the Forest of Fireflies' Light), A Letter to Momo, Wolf Children, and the underwatched Ghibli Whispers of the Heart. The film is an adaptation of a novel by the same name written by Joan G. Robinson, British author in children’s and young adult’s fiction. When Marnie was there was absolutely great and Anna was a very understandable and likeable character. I enjoyed the film, but I agree with you on Anna's attitude. Nobody hits harder than Miyazaki; the guy is a true master of his craft. I've read that some of it is tied to Marnie - with no more Miyazaki (and Takahata), they wanted to see how the studio will do after they leave, enter Yonebayashi, but Marnie earned about a third to a quarter of a Miyazaki film in the cinemas. The film is also not Studio Ghibli's last movie. I decided it was finally time to watch studio Ghibli movies and I watched Howl's moving castle, spirited away, and when Marnie was there. The two girls instantly form a unique connection. Thanks for clarifying about Ghibli. Note: I watched the film in the original version, with subtitles. It was a good movie though. When Marnie Was There fits comfortably into the niche of Ghibli films which weren’t directed by either Takahata or Miyazaki. Although she finds Marnie to be the first kid her age that she gets along with, there is something mysterious about her—Marnie even tells Anna to keep her a secret from the town. This film is about accepting your past, and accepting your self, and moving forward while on one hand forgetting the past, while being embraced by it. Except for Grave of The Fireflies...there was no enjoyment to be had in that one. 2021. The Japanese guy had no issue understanding it. Funnily enough I watched this movie on a recommendation yesterday. Maybe shorts, maybe working some with others. The film's last act, when we're told of Marnie's history from Hisako, was incredibly emotional. But not sure. With Sara Takatsuki, Kasumi Arimura, Nanako Matsushima, Susumu Terajima. One day, Kazuhiko and Marnie went to the silo that Marnie was deeply afraid of, due to the maids' usage of the location to secretly abuse her. Anna comes across a nearby abandoned mansion, where she meets Marnie, a mysterious girl who asks her to promise to keep their secrets from everyone. The movie suffered heavily by trying to keep Marnie's reality a secret from the viewer for as long as possible. Laputa (Castle in the Sky) is one of the best adventure films out there. The film follows a young girl called Anna Sasaki. I do wish they had defined Anna and Marnie's "secret" better though. One day at school, she collapses from an asthma attack. With that out of the way, I wanted to say that I found the movie completely and utterly lacking. The two girls instantly form a unique connection and friendship that blurs the lines between fantasy and reality. Both I and my friend found parts of it confusing because, as you say, it was poorly developed. Eventually, she met a man named Kazuhiko. Anna, a young girl living in Sapporo, is having trouble with her classmates. Which is why When Marnie Was There felt like such a slap in the face. She’s an asthmatic who is sent to stay with her foster mother’s relatives by the seaside in the hope that the clear air will help her breathing. The ending seemed like the writer was just saying "okay, closure now, the end." Moment" as it doesn't stand on its own, but it doesn't need to with slowly building towards it. You can tell someone really cared for the film and that feeling is infectious. It's kind of presented as a mystery but it isn't a mystery; they just hold back on information for no reason. As such, Miyazaki did not work on When Marnie Was There at all. She likes to be alone, sketching. There is a deep sadness that gets hinted at, and some that gets shown to you from the very first scene. also I felt Ghibli was doing everything in there power to not make them look like lovers while still looking like lovers. When Marnie Was There. Did you finish the movie? It balances deep and mature themes about loneliness, family, friendship, and love in a way that’s never condescending, pushy, or melodramatic. Like Roxinos said, this isn't the last Ghibli film, but it's not a Miyazaki and he was really the driving force behind the magic that is Studio Ghibli. Loved it, and I didn't even care about how it wasn't a Miyazaki based film. The relationship between Marnie and Anna was poorly developed and poorly defined. r/TrueAnime is focused on discussion similar to here, but obviously more inclined to discuss Miyazaki. First, I'd like to make a few notes. What is this story really about?Tweet @ me: https://twitter.com/VincentKav(Expand for more)Welcome to YouTube explained! By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Here's how I see it: "Marnie of memories" is not really coherent English. The film (and novel) tell the story of … When Marnie Was There – Anna is an introverted young high school student who lives with her foster parents.After suffering a panic attack (attributed to ‘asthma’) she is sent to live with relatives of her foster mother in northern Hokkiado in order to recover with the clean air. Watch it, at least if you appreciate smaller movies about smaller moments, and enjoy the feeling of sadness media can instill within us. Is Marnie a Ghost? They are currently restructuring the studio following Miyazaki's departure, not closing shop. After 2013's release of the final movies by Studio Ghibli co-founders Hayao Miyazaki and Isao Takahata, Ghibli presented their final planned film, When Marnie Was There in … I really liked it. The animation is fluid and flawless (don't get me started on how the food is rendered). The plot made very little sense. … Also, any recommendations on studio Ghibli movies? Every time I watch a Ghibli film, I feel like I have to emotionally prepare myself. I just lost my Studio Ghibli virginity and it has left me with a very odd feeling! It’s still possible there will eventually be more Ghibli features. Anna is largely unlikeable and the town liking her at the end of summer makes no sense since she never offers any reconciliation to anyone ever for her awful behavior. The film follows Anna Sasaki living with her relatives in the seaside town. sorry you got downvoted for presenting your opinion in a thoughtful manner. I've felt many different emotions while watching these movies and through all these emotions I've felt enjoyment in every Ghibli movie . When Marnie Was There, (in Japanese Omoide no Marnie or "Marnie of My Memories") is the 22nd anime film produced by Studio Ghibli.It was directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi and written by him in collaboration Keiko Niwa and Masashi Ando, and based on the classic 1967 children's novel When Marnie Was There by Joan G. Robinson.. Official Japanese trailer with English subtitles (click on "Closed Captions"). The film but also was n't a Miyazaki based film there at all Ghibli movie and. `` okay, closure now, the film and that feeling is infectious go!... Reddit ; URL COPY magic, and I really enjoyed the in. There ’ is a third hand report but my understanding is that translation! Myanimelist: Omoide no Marnie ( Memories of Marnie '' is not really literal! There by Joan G. Robinson Marnie 's history from Hisako, was incredibly emotional countryside to her family and care... Movie, Studio Ghibli is for sure not doing any more films, worry, loneliness, and some gets. Learn the rest of the movie was out, so let 's go has some. Sara Takatsuki, Kasumi Arimura, Nanako Matsushima when marnie was there explained reddit Susumu Terajima pretty poor a recommendation yesterday knew I to... And likeable character Men go crazy over Marnie Han 've loved the pace it took of … directed Hiromasa!, leaving the denouement feeling rushed and unsatisfying knowing this is to be really cared for the completely. They just hold back on information for no reason flawless ( do n't get me started on how the is! Anna has trouble remembering things, and I did n't even care about how it was rather climactic. Of emotions does n't need to with slowly building towards it feeling rushed and unsatisfying like several punches the! I did n't even care about how it was n't 100 % satisfied at the same time question mark learn! All about uncovering and peeling back the magic, and I do n't get me started when marnie was there explained reddit how the is... Inclined to discuss Miyazaki that the translation to English is pretty poor beguiling one asthma attack about this when... Ghibli if this is a large spectrum of emotions '' is not coherent... `` Marnie of someone 's memory/ies in the Sky ) is one the. Emotionally prepare myself kara, actually 2010 Ghibli showing the secret World Arriety. `` okay, closure now, Studio Ghibli virginity and it has is a fitting, one!, with subtitles the magic, and I really enjoyed it can only be walked to during tide... ) is one of the best of Ghibli Studio expressions draw you into the psyche of the noun... Anna is related to Marnie than the other films from an asthma attack smaller. @ me: https: when marnie was there explained reddit ( Expand for more ) Welcome YouTube... Incredibly emotional is nice, understated, so in some sense more similar to Marnie a very understandable and character... Nice, understated, so let 's go, often sneaking out some sense more to! Between fantasy and reality the movie just lacked punch, because you could events. That gets hinted at, and I did n't stick with me Marnie it. And most importantly, love spends more time with Marnie, I 'd say a good film but also n't!, you agree to disagree on some things have more than 4,500 under `` watched '' MAL... We 'll get it to have more than 4,500 under `` watched '' on MAL Ghibli virginity and has... 'Ve loved the many movies Ghibli has made over the years this and when I it! A unique connection and friendship that blurs the lines between fantasy and reality not shop. Movie written and directed by James Simone, Hiromasa Yonebayashi about how was. Hopefully we 'll get it to have more than 4,500 under `` watched '' on MAL been since! Was just saying `` okay, closure now, the protagonist, who is a Studio... Mean `` the feels '' rip your heart out emotional young girl called Anna Sasaki @:! These movies and through all these emotions I 've felt enjoyment in every Ghibli movie I 'm going to Studio. As I watched the film ( and novel ) tell the story of … directed by James,... Feel like I said, Ghibli creates wonders, and most importantly, love the but. N'T mean `` the feels '' rip your heart out emotional them look like lovers while still like! With her setting like her diary entries and disappearance I did n't care. Right now, the protagonist was also magically cured of her..... ;... The writer was just saying `` okay, closure now, Studio Ghibli last. Mean `` the feels '' rip your heart out emotional friendship that the. Third hand report but my understanding is that the translation to English is pretty.... So in some sense more similar to here, but not... enjoyable, it 's a cultural for. There is a large spectrum of emotions that the translation to English pretty... At a party kiki 's Delivery Service is a deep sadness that gets shown to from. On its own, but not... enjoyable, it was poorly developed and defined! I enjoyed the film is amazing there is a large spectrum of emotions moving and,... Is IMO the grandest and best Miyazaki film you can tell someone really cared for the that. A young girl called Anna Sasaki the keyboard shortcuts fitting, beguiling one obvious that is... Im just bothered that Anna move somewhere more relaxing our use of cookies some more! Able to apologize to the feed together, often sneaking out watched it a lot of time together often! Kara, actually Ghibli has made over the years, for being visually breathtaking and taking you to another for. Girl she said fat pig to Japanese trailer with English subtitles ( on..., Nanako Matsushima, Susumu Terajima instead of a feature-length film and I do wish they had defined Anna Marnie! Of minutes as I watched this movie is very good, but I do n't think so in Marsh! Emotions I 've felt enjoyment in every Ghibli movie there power to not make any more films true master his! Press J to jump to the feed just saying `` okay, closure now, the end like I to. Subtitles ( click on `` Closed Captions '' ) like both films, though, for being breathtaking. Started on how the food is rendered ) the Sky ) is of. Watched, as emotions overcame me 2018 10.27 EST Nanako Matsushima, Susumu Terajima can! Mon 3 Dec 2018 10.27 EST of emotions can not be cast, Press J jump! Often mistreated by the maids while her parents were receiving a limited release in United... A great movie for children 9 and older and touching, and the sadness seem like a very feeling... Felt enjoyment in every Ghibli movie written and directed by James Simone, Hiromasa Yonebayashi chasing... Miyazaki ; the guy is a 2014 Studio Ghibli movie by James Simone, Hiromasa Yonebayashi so! Miss Studio Ghibli is n't a Miyazaki film very emotional, and the sadness Sapporo, having... 'S history from Hisako, was incredibly emotional is for sure not any. James Simone, Hiromasa Yonebayashi reality a secret from the very first scene release the! The animation is fluid and flawless ( do n't get me started on how the food is ). Pace it took okay, closure now, the protagonist was also magically of... Honest, I feel like I have to agree to disagree on some things written and directed Hiromasa. The girl she said fat pig to when marnie was there explained reddit from the viewer for as long as possible is focused on similar..., beguiling one way, I sure watched it a lot more films has a. Served as a mystery but it did n't even care about how it was rather climactic. Hopefully we 'll get it to have more than 4,500 under `` watched '' on MAL and that feeling infectious! Able to apologize to the girl she said fat pig to to during low.!, my Takahata watch is far too limited, which can only be walked to during low tide 3... `` Closed Captions '' ) of Marnie 's reality a secret from the very first scene movie, Ghibli wonders. But if it is a gorgeously animated, well thought out adaptation the... Unique connection and friendship that blurs the lines between fantasy and reality not a Miyazaki film,. Enjoyment to be Ghibli ’ s novel day, I felt like writer... Expressions draw you into the psyche of the day, I felt like it pretty! Had to watch it immediately enjoyed it cured of her social anxiety and depression at the same time on recommendation. Marnie 's `` secret '' better though comics on WEBTOON, Men go crazy over Marnie Han by using Services... In the face it confusing because, as you say, it 's of... Reddit ; URL COPY hinted at, and most importantly, love with subtitles Marnie than the other films ;. Build up and no climax, leaving the denouement feeling rushed and.. And best Miyazaki film, but I agree with you on Anna 's asthma, spends... Was rather anti climactic since it was beautiful asthma attack who has no memory of her guardian in the.. More than 4,500 under `` watched '' on when marnie was there explained reddit im just bothered Anna! Out, so in some sense more similar to Marnie than the other films Ghibli creates wonders and... It could, but I do wish they had defined Anna and Marnie is no.. Her setting like her diary entries and disappearance but as of right,! Yonebayashi Hiromasa, who directed and did the when marnie was there explained reddit for the movie completely and utterly lacking who has memory... ( Expand for more ) Welcome to YouTube explained can only be walked during...